Care sector employment · 8 minute read

What the Employment Rights Act Means for Care Providers

Day one sick pay, earlier unfair dismissal rights, guaranteed hours and third party harassment will reshape how care homes and domiciliary providers staff, review and protect their teams.

A sunlit corridor of frosted glass panels and pale stone columns with a navy doorway and a thin line of orange light
Illustrative image

Care providers rely on flexible contracting, which leaves them particularly exposed to the Employment Rights Act 2025. Employment costs already make up between seventy and eighty per cent of a typical care provider’s operating budget, and Care England estimates that the Act will add at least ten per cent to those costs once it is fully implemented.

Taken together with higher employers’ National Insurance and the newly announced increase in the minimum wage, there is real concern that many providers will face closure or look to sell to a large group with deep pockets.

Budget for sick pay from the first day

Since 6th April 2026, the three waiting days and the lower earnings limit for Statutory Sick Pay have been abolished. Eligible workers receive £123.25 a week or eighty per cent of their average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, from their first day of absence.

This seemingly minor adjustment carries a significant cost for adult social care. Residential and domiciliary models rely heavily on short shifts and part time patterns. Previously, an absent worker had to be replaced, but the absence itself created no additional cost. Routine sickness now becomes an immediate, unbudgeted expense.

In a sector inherently exposed to infectious illness, day one sick pay will arise frequently. Providers will need to build higher absence contingencies into their hourly rate negotiations with local authorities and private clients, and margins will narrow wherever commissioners refuse to absorb the difference.

Prepare for earlier unfair dismissal rights

The government’s timetable provides for the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal claims to fall from two years to six months for dismissals from 1st January 2027. Employers will no longer be able to treat the early months of employment as a period in which they can end employment without a fair reason and a fair process.

The law does not prescribe a fixed statutory probation timetable, but dismissing a new recruit fairly will require a documented reason and a proportionate process from the start. That hits adult social care harder than most industries. The CQC expects rigorous evidence of staff competence and safety, yet around two thirds of new entrants arrive with no previous care experience or relevant qualifications.

In an understaffed home or domiciliary service, the first three to four months of an untrained recruit’s employment are largely taken up by induction, shadowing and assessment against the sixteen standards of the Care Certificate. That leaves a narrow window of independent work in which to judge whether a recruit has the values, resilience and safe practice the role demands.

Managers will need to act as trainers and reviewers at the same time, recording progress at regular intervals. Where practice is borderline, waiting for gradual improvement becomes risky. The six month point forces an early choice between a well evidenced, fair dismissal and allowing an unsuitable employee to acquire full unfair dismissal rights.

Annual staff turnover of 22.1 per cent compounds the strain, trapping providers in a continuous cycle of recruitment and early review. Smaller independent operators often lack the internal HR capacity to maintain the records needed to defend a tribunal claim. Larger groups may have systems to track milestones, but the volume of concurrent reviews places a heavy burden on regional management. Providers risk being penalised not for failing to manage staff on the ground, but for being unable to prove it on paper.

Plan for guaranteed hours and cancelled shifts

The Act provides for workers on zero hours contracts who work regular hours over a reference period to be offered guaranteed hours reflecting those hours, together with reasonable notice of shifts and payment for shifts cancelled or cut at short notice. These measures are expected from 2027, with the detail, including a proposed twelve week reference period, to be confirmed in regulations.

With around half of all domiciliary care workers on zero hours contracts, this creates a serious clash between commissioning and employment law. Local authorities commission care by the minute. If a service user is admitted to hospital, dies or declines care on arrival, the provider receives nothing for that visit. Today the worker is stood down unpaid. Under the new rules, the provider is likely to have to compensate the worker from its own reserves.

For a provider operating on a net margin of three to five per cent, paying for one unbillable hour can wipe out the profit from twenty successful visits. A look back period also assumes a stability social care rarely enjoys. Managers will need to separate predictable long term packages from volatile demand, matching guaranteed contracts to the first while absorbing the financial risk of the second.

Large operators are better insulated. Scale brings reserves to absorb unbillable wages, but their main advantage is geographical density. When a visit is cancelled, a provider with many nearby clients can redeploy the worker and convert the shift back into billable time. Large groups also have the leverage to negotiate block contracts, securing income that avoids the risk of spot purchasing. Independent providers rarely have either option.

Protect staff from third party harassment

Employers already have a duty to take reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, introduced by the Worker Protection (Amendment of Equality Act 2010) Act 2023. The Employment Rights Act strengthens this to all reasonable steps and makes employers liable for harassment of their staff by third parties, including service users, relatives and visitors, unless they have taken all reasonable steps to prevent it. Because these claims sit within the Equality Act, compensation is uncapped and can include substantial awards for injury to feelings.

The premise is valid, but the mechanism sits awkwardly with social care. The law is conceptually built for retail or hospitality, where an employer can ban an abusive customer. In care, the person displaying challenging behaviour is often a resident with advanced dementia or severe cognitive impairment, or a highly distressed relative.

A provider cannot simply withdraw care from a vulnerable person without risking breaches of CQC regulations and commissioning contracts. The Equality and Human Rights Commission’s guidance expects reasonable steps to be tailored to the setting, but offers no specific safe harbour for care providers. In practice, that means detailed risk assessments rather than blanket bans.

Defending a claim will require a clear evidence trail. Reasonable steps in care mean dynamic risk assessments, strict lone working protocols, de-escalation training tailored to individual residents’ triggers and robust incident logging.

Smaller operators often lack the HR and compliance capacity to maintain this level of protection and face a disproportionate risk of litigation. Larger groups face the same problem on a wider surface area. Widespread monitoring failures can prompt investigations by the EHRC and the CQC, threatening contracts and damaging recruitment. Heavy reliance on agency and relief staff adds to the challenge, because temporary workers must be briefed on residents’ triggers and lone working protocols before every shift. The strongest defence is evidence of active enforcement through spot checks, audits and pre-shift briefings.

Respond with defensible systems

Care employers should treat these changes as an operational overhaul rather than an abstract legal update. Several reforms are already in force and others follow in 2027.

  • Audit flexible contracts. Review zero hours and casual workers to identify regular patterns of work. Separate core guaranteed hours from genuinely variable relief cover to protect your wage bill from unbillable downtime. We can manage this for you on an ongoing basis or provide the training and systems for your team to do it in house.

  • Upgrade rostering and cancellation procedures. Make sure your systems track shift notice, flag late cancellations that may require payment and monitor absence patterns from the first day.

  • Restructure early employment reviews. Rewrite onboarding policies so performance is reviewed and recorded from the first week, giving managers the tools to make fair, lawful decisions before the six month point where appropriate. We can put these procedures in place, manage the process, train your staff or provide the toolkit you need.

  • Use resident specific risk assessments. Blanket anti-harassment policies will not survive a tribunal. Introduce behavioural risk assessments for individual residents and ask agency staff to sign pre-shift briefings covering lone working protocols and known triggers.

  • Model the cost and test compliance. Stress test payroll against day one sick pay and expected wage increases, and use spot checks and mystery shopping to confirm that practice matches policy. Loopol can carry out these stress tests, audits and mystery shops on your behalf.

Talk to Loopol

Without records showing that fair procedures were followed, an employment tribunal may conclude that they were not followed in practice.

To discuss anything raised in this article, email helloloopol@gmail.com or get in touch to arrange a call or meeting.

Get in touch about your employment arrangements

Tell us about your organisation and what you would like to review, such as contracts, probation, sick pay, rostering or harassment prevention. Please do not include staff names or personal details in your first message.

Selected: Policies & processes
All articles