Governance · 8 minute read

Protect your supply chain from corporate criminal liability

Understand the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and build a defensible framework to prevent the criminal facilitation of tax evasion.

Grid of deep concrete openings on a modern facade at twilight
Illustrative image

In the modern regulatory landscape, a company's liability no longer stops at its own payroll. Under the Criminal Finances Act 2017, your company can be prosecuted if an associated person, such as an employee, agent or subcontractor acting on your behalf, criminally facilitates tax evasion.

Understanding the background to the legislation, how it works in practice and how to build defensive guardrails around it should be an integral part of the operations of any business today.

Understand why the Act was introduced

The Criminal Finances Act 2017 was enacted following global scrutiny over corporate transparency and tax manipulation, intensified by the fallout of the Panama Papers leak.

Before its introduction, prosecuting a corporate entity for these offences was difficult because of the identification principle. Prosecutors generally had to attribute the relevant conduct and state of mind to a person who represented the company's directing mind and will, typically a board member or senior executive. In large organisations, this could make it difficult to establish corporate responsibility for criminal facilitation happening further down the chain.

The Act was introduced to address that difficulty. Modelled on the failure to prevent framework of the Bribery Act 2010, it shifted the focus towards prevention. Management ignorance does not, by itself, provide a defence.

Recognise how criminal liability arises

The legislation establishes two corporate criminal offences: failure to prevent the facilitation of UK tax evasion and failure to prevent the facilitation of foreign tax evasion. Liability follows a three stage test:

  • Criminal tax evasion. A taxpayer, whether an individual or a company, criminally evades tax, for example by deliberately hiding taxable income or dishonestly evading VAT. An error or an unpaid tax bill does not, on its own, establish criminal evasion.

  • Criminal facilitation. An associated person acting on behalf of your business deliberately helps the taxpayer to commit the evasion. A supplier's wrongdoing does not automatically make your business liable: the person's role and criminal conduct matter.

  • Corporate failure to prevent. Your corporate entity fails to prevent that associated person from criminally facilitating the evasion, subject to the statutory prevention defence.

The prosecution does not need to prove that your directors knew about the facilitation, approved it or profited from it. However, the underlying evasion and deliberate criminal facilitation still have to be established. The foreign tax offence also has additional requirements concerning a UK connection and criminality in both jurisdictions.

A business can defend itself by showing that it had reasonable prevention procedures in place, or that it was not reasonable in the circumstances to expect it to have such procedures. A conviction can lead to an unlimited fine and serious reputational damage, with other orders potentially available where the legal conditions are met.

Assess enforcement risk across your sector

HMRC investigates suspected corporate failures to prevent the facilitation of tax evasion. A business should prepare for scrutiny by understanding its exposure and keeping evidence of the prevention measures it actually follows, rather than relying on a policy which exists only on paper.

The offences apply to bodies corporate and partnerships, including relevant overseas entities. Extended, fragmented supply chains can create particular risk in the following sectors:

  • Construction and trade. Layers of main contractors, subcontractors and labour suppliers can create blind spots around payroll, invoicing and tax reporting. Cash payments and Construction Industry Scheme arrangements are not inherently unlawful, but deliberate arrangements to facilitate evasion require close attention.

  • Logistics and transport. Cascading tiers of operators, hauliers and agency drivers can create exposure to dishonest payroll arrangements, false invoicing and fuel transaction fraud. The relevant question is whether someone acting on the business's behalf deliberately facilitates tax evasion.

  • Property development and the built environment. Complex capital flows, contracting layers and international suppliers can make fraudulent invoicing or deliberate tax facilitation harder to detect. Procurement corruption may create additional risks under separate legislation.

  • Recruitment and staffing agencies. Temporary worker supply chains, umbrella companies and offshore payroll providers require careful scrutiny. Intermediaries which deliberately facilitate the evasion of PAYE or National Insurance can expose associated businesses to significant risk.

  • Care and health services. Reliance on staffing agencies, temporary rotas and international recruitment can make payroll arrangements difficult to oversee. Criminal tax evasion must be distinguished from lawful tax planning. Right to work failures are a separate compliance issue and do not, by themselves, establish an offence under this Act.

  • Property and housing. Significant capital inflows, rent collection and property transactions can create opportunities for deliberate concealment of taxable income or dishonest valuations. Accepting cash or encountering unauthorised subletting is not, by itself, evidence of criminal tax facilitation.

Build reasonable prevention procedures

The statutory defence focuses on the prevention procedures in place when the facilitation occurred and whether those procedures were reasonable in the circumstances. The legislation also recognises circumstances in which it would not be reasonable to expect a business to have prevention procedures.

HMRC's guidance sets out six principles to inform a proportionate prevention framework:

  • Risk assessment. Conduct a documented review to identify where your business is exposed to potential criminal tax facilitation across its operations and supply chain.

  • Proportionality. Scale your prevention policies to the actual size, complexity and risk level of your operations.

  • Senior management commitment. Ensure senior management actively leads, reviews and reinforces a culture which rejects the criminal facilitation of tax evasion.

  • Due diligence. Apply clear, structured checks to associated persons, including relevant subcontractors, agents and suppliers, according to the risks they present.

  • Communication and training. Ensure staff and relevant associated persons understand what criminal tax facilitation looks like and how to report concerns internally.

  • Monitoring and review. Regularly test and update your prevention framework as your operations, risks and applicable requirements change.

Discuss practical supply chain support with Loopol

Mitigating supply chain risk requires turning passive trust into active, documented compliance. Loopol can help you clarify the controls, responsibilities and records your business needs, with the scope agreed around your operations:

  • Supply chain risk assessments. Review your supplier and subcontractor arrangements to identify compliance gaps and matters requiring specialist advice.

  • Contract and policy review. Review relevant clauses, compliance declarations and audit rights as part of an agreed governance engagement. Contract wording alone does not establish reasonable prevention procedures or guarantee a defence.

  • Documented verification. Support agreed supplier, worker and qualification checks with clear records and escalation routes. Our supply chain verification pack and managed service do not include tax, CIS or VAT administration, or specialist payroll and tax compliance vetting.

To discuss your supply chain controls or the support you need, contact Loopol at helloloopol@gmail.com. Tax evasion concerns and specialist HMRC matters should also be referred to an appropriately qualified tax adviser or lawyer.

All articles